5w40 or 10w40 oil? Benzine excess consumption?

Le forum pour les gens qui aiment avoir les mains sales.
MOTEUR - REFROIDISSEMENT - TRAINS ROULANTS
Avatar du membre
amilo123
Membre SR
Membre SR
Messages : 222
Enregistré le : 20 mars 2011, 14:13
Modèle(s) 309 : GT
Localisation : Bucharest, Romania
Contact :

5w40 or 10w40 oil? Benzine excess consumption?

Message par amilo123 » 20 mars 2011, 14:14

Hi, I have a 1986 Peugeot 309 GT with 176000km and the 82kW XU92C engine.

Currently I have a semi-synthetic elf competition ST 10w40 oil which I want to change. I know it is a poor quality oil and I want a higher quality one. Someone told me that any engine would benefit from a change from 10w to 5w, is this true of this engine?

I was looking at the Total quartz 9000 (5w40) or the quartz 7000 (10w40)...anything better than these?

thank you!
1986 Peugeot 309GT 1.9l ~201 000 km

Avatar du membre
alargeau
ADHÉRENT
ADHÉRENT
Messages : 7581
Enregistré le : 24 mars 2006, 16:12
Modèle(s) 309 : SL - GTI
Localisation : Var
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par alargeau » 20 mars 2011, 14:25

Hello,
First of all, you need to introduce yourself in the appropriate section.
Then, Peugeot recommends 10w40 oils. I don't think there's any benefit in putting a 5W40 oil in those engines. Plus when they're old, they tend to leak so a more viscous oil is not recommended. I buy 10W40 oils for both of my 309s (GTI and non-GTI) and the Total Quartz 7000 is a very good oil. There's the Castrol GTX too.
Rejoignez notre association et bénéficiez d'avantages sur les pièces détachées - Join us and enjoy great deals on any part you want!
Image

Avatar du membre
Thomas 309
Membre GL
Membre GL
Messages : 84
Enregistré le : 04 juin 2009, 19:05
Modèle(s) 309 : Graffic
Localisation : Kornwestheim -Germany-
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par Thomas 309 » 20 mars 2011, 19:19

Hi,

I am the same opinion as Aurélien. The motors are designed for 10W40 and work with it perfectly. I always use 10W40 oil that is filled at Peugeot every year (original Peugeot Oil from my Peugeot-dealer). Only poorer quality, I would not recommend it. However, But I've also thought about to try 5W40 or 5W30 oil...

Regards, Thomas (is already looking forward to get back its 309 Graffic from hibernation in two weeks-and than DRIVING)

My vehicles:

PEUGEOT 309 Graffic 1992
Wartburg 353S 1987
Nissan Leaf e+ 62 kWh 2021
SIMSON Schwalbe KR51/1
SIMSON SR50 B4

Avatar du membre
beni
ADHÉRENT
ADHÉRENT
Messages : 987
Enregistré le : 20 févr. 2009, 23:11
Modèle(s) 309 : Grrrrrrrrr
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par beni » 20 mars 2011, 19:35

I already tried 5W40 (on a XU5-2C) and I will advise against it ...

The engine uses too much oil, probably because it is more fluid.

Avatar du membre
thefunkyboy
RESP. SORTIES
RESP. SORTIES
Messages : 14795
Enregistré le : 07 janv. 2008, 21:11
Localisation : Toulouse

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par thefunkyboy » 20 mars 2011, 21:06

On a XU engine 8 valves, the best viscosity is 10W40. On a TU engine, I prefer the 15W40 (less noise because of the tippers)
GB:
http://www.peugeot309.net/En/Forum/sear ... d=newposts" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Image

Avatar du membre
amilo123
Membre SR
Membre SR
Messages : 222
Enregistré le : 20 mars 2011, 14:13
Modèle(s) 309 : GT
Localisation : Bucharest, Romania
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par amilo123 » 21 mars 2011, 01:14

thank you very much for the responses! I will put the quartz 7000 oil today

as long as I am here, may I ask, how hard/expensive is it to put air conditioning in this model?
1986 Peugeot 309GT 1.9l ~201 000 km

Avatar du membre
thefunkyboy
RESP. SORTIES
RESP. SORTIES
Messages : 14795
Enregistré le : 07 janv. 2008, 21:11
Localisation : Toulouse

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par thefunkyboy » 21 mars 2011, 07:55

Can you open another topic for this question?

The most appropriated person to answer to this question is Baptiste (SRDTurbo) :cote:
GB:
http://www.peugeot309.net/En/Forum/sear ... d=newposts" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Image

Avatar du membre
amilo123
Membre SR
Membre SR
Messages : 222
Enregistré le : 20 mars 2011, 14:13
Modèle(s) 309 : GT
Localisation : Bucharest, Romania
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par amilo123 » 21 mars 2011, 14:06

In the end I went with the total quartz 7000 energy (10w40), I put it in today.

I hope this solves the problem with the oil getting very hot, around 115 degrees
1986 Peugeot 309GT 1.9l ~201 000 km

Avatar du membre
alargeau
ADHÉRENT
ADHÉRENT
Messages : 7581
Enregistré le : 24 mars 2006, 16:12
Modèle(s) 309 : SL - GTI
Localisation : Var
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par alargeau » 21 mars 2011, 14:11

I don't think the oil is the problem. I have used the Elf Competition ST in the past and even though it's not the best oil on the market, it's definitely not the worst and is way above average.
Rejoignez notre association et bénéficiez d'avantages sur les pièces détachées - Join us and enjoy great deals on any part you want!
Image

Avatar du membre
thefunkyboy
RESP. SORTIES
RESP. SORTIES
Messages : 14795
Enregistré le : 07 janv. 2008, 21:11
Localisation : Toulouse

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par thefunkyboy » 21 mars 2011, 15:04

The Shell hellix plus is a good one,10w40
GB:
http://www.peugeot309.net/En/Forum/sear ... d=newposts" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Image

Avatar du membre
amilo123
Membre SR
Membre SR
Messages : 222
Enregistré le : 20 mars 2011, 14:13
Modèle(s) 309 : GT
Localisation : Bucharest, Romania
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par amilo123 » 21 mars 2011, 16:12

well what could the problem be then? should I be worried?
1986 Peugeot 309GT 1.9l ~201 000 km

Avatar du membre
thefunkyboy
RESP. SORTIES
RESP. SORTIES
Messages : 14795
Enregistré le : 07 janv. 2008, 21:11
Localisation : Toulouse

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par thefunkyboy » 21 mars 2011, 17:32

It depends. Does your sensor work properly?

My GT used to have a high oil temperature. I never found the origine
GB:
http://www.peugeot309.net/En/Forum/sear ... d=newposts" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Image

Avatar du membre
amilo123
Membre SR
Membre SR
Messages : 222
Enregistré le : 20 mars 2011, 14:13
Modèle(s) 309 : GT
Localisation : Bucharest, Romania
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par amilo123 » 21 mars 2011, 19:02

thefunkyboy a écrit :It depends. Does your sensor work properly?

My GT used to have a high oil temperature. I never found the origine
I'm not sure. Last year, in the summer it rarely reached 100. And now even in this rather cold weather, when I drive more it reaches 110-115, the water stays at 70-80.

Almost all the coolant is new and the water pump as well, also I removed the air from the cooling system, but only through one of the holes, the one behind the air filter. I know from my mechanic that there is another one just above the engine, but he says the cap is stuck and he advised against forcing it...

When it was newer, 5-7 years ago, the oil stayed at exactly 90
1986 Peugeot 309GT 1.9l ~201 000 km

Avatar du membre
thefunkyboy
RESP. SORTIES
RESP. SORTIES
Messages : 14795
Enregistré le : 07 janv. 2008, 21:11
Localisation : Toulouse

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par thefunkyboy » 21 mars 2011, 19:16

Is your Igniter well calibrated? (too much advance can create that oil temperature phenomena)
GB:
http://www.peugeot309.net/En/Forum/sear ... d=newposts" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Image

Avatar du membre
amilo123
Membre SR
Membre SR
Messages : 222
Enregistré le : 20 mars 2011, 14:13
Modèle(s) 309 : GT
Localisation : Bucharest, Romania
Contact :

Re: 5w40 or 10w40 oil?

Message par amilo123 » 21 mars 2011, 19:42

thefunkyboy a écrit :Is your Igniter well calibrated? (too much advance can create that oil temperature phenomena)
Well, I don't know about that... And I don't think my mechanic knows how to calibrate it.

I saw that the idle speed isn't smooth at all... The carburetor was calibrated last summer, but I think I need to go again to that guy...

The mileage I get isn't either as it says in the book... It consumes 13.5 l/100km, last I checked, but this could be because of the cold weather to. In december I got 16 l/100km lol
1986 Peugeot 309GT 1.9l ~201 000 km

Répondre